Apr. 24th, 2017 07:27 pm
daibhidc: (Doctor Who)
[personal profile] daibhidc
The Doctor and Bill were great, the story could have been better, but I think I quite enjoyed it.

The emojibots were ridiculous, but the Doctor thinks so as well, so they get away with it.

Valencia City of Art and Science is gorgeous, and it's almost a shame there was a story happening at all, and we weren't just panning round it the whole episode. But we got a lot of panning round it, and it was gorgeous throughout.

The plot was a bit all over the place. I never quite bought the central concept of the robots killing because they don't understand sadness. And even if you do accept the whole "they see it as a plague" thing, why did they leave it long enough for Patient Zero - the person whose death triggered the whole thing - to be treated with due reverence? Also, these people's entire planet had died, a tiny fraction of the population had made it, and there was nothing that made them sad prior to this?

And the ending ... well, it was Margaret Slitheen only not sold as well, really. It just about works, but comes very close to not.

And then they're at the frost fair! Never mind Original Flavour Cybermen, it seems like we going full 1963 every-story-ends-with-a-cliffhanger-to-the-next.

Date: 2017-04-24 07:59 pm (UTC)
capriuni: A black field crossed by five parallel lighting bolts in blue, gold, green, red, and purple (Default)
From: [personal profile] capriuni
Mostly, I was just grateful it didn't end with: "A.I. is evil! Destroy all the Robots!"

I also thought Pearl Mackie was excellent again.

And this story was a lot better than "Forest of the Night" (It would have been hard to make it any worse).

But, yeah... The more I think about it, the more I can imagine ways to make the story less of a mess:

1) Instead of having the Doctor erase the emojibots' memories, just delete the command lines that orders them to be responsible for the humans (break the chains of their slavery) and that they must disallow any sadness.

2) Cut out the scene with the blue jelly, and use those minutes to give more time to the ending, so it's not so rushed.

3) Pick a theme and stick to it: is it the nature of grief? The emergence of sentience? Anti-Colonialism? Etc.

Date: 2017-04-25 06:56 am (UTC)
julesjones: (Default)
From: [personal profile] julesjones
As mash-ups pf "Silence in the Library" and "The Happiness Patrol" go, it wasn't half bad.

I did like it a lot,even with its problems, and it's a great Bill story - I love her sense of joy and wonder at the things the Doctor is showing her.


daibhidc: (Default)
Daibhid C

September 2017

10111213 141516
17 181920212223

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 21st, 2017 09:25 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios